After Further Review: Tagliabue's ruling not a win for Saints - FOX 8 WVUE New Orleans News, Weather, Sports

After Further Review: Tagliabue's ruling not a win for Saints


The decision was stunning. Count me as one of the many shocked that Paul Tagliabue vacated all player discipline from the bounty fallout.

The players say they're vindicated with the ruling. But don't confuse vindication with victory. The Saints did not win with Tuesday's ruling.

Of all the suspensions, fines and lost draft picks the NFL handed the Saints, only one truly mattered enough to make this their first irrelevant December since the dreaded Katrina season of 2005.

As I combed through Tagliabue's 22-page decision, Sean Payton's name was not on the list of vacated suspensions.  And in my view, that's the only one that truly mattered.

Jonathan Vilma's, Will Smith's, Mickey Loomis' and Joe Vitt's punishments were clearly harsh and difficult for each person. But they weren't enough to cripple an entire season.

Payton's season-long dagger was.

Smith didn't miss a game all season. Vilma didn't miss a game due to suspension. Did it really matter? They're still sitting at 5-8 and playing for a defense that, while they've improved, at one point in the season was flirting with records -- and not the records the Saints have been accustomed to under Payton.

Without Payton, the Saints have looked very un-Saints-like. They've been consistently inconsistent -- capable of flashes of greatness, but it came in teases, not true threats. And it's that constant up-and-down that's convinced me how sorely they missed their true commander in chief.

In terms of paychecks and games (not reputation), Tuesday's ruling essentially gave Saints players back something they never really lost.

But what was lost, Tagliabue made sure would never be returned: the 2012 Saints season.

Powered by WorldNow

Louisiana Media Company, LLC.
1025 S. Jefferson Davis Parkway
New Orleans, LA 70125

General Number: (504) 486-6161
News Tips: (504) 483-1503
News Room Fax: (504) 483-1543

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and WVUE. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
WVUE's Public Inspection File can now be accessed online. To access the online public inspection file click here: