Judge tosses ex-BP executive's obstruction charge - FOX 8 WVUE New Orleans News, Weather, Sports, Social

Judge tosses ex-BP executive's obstruction charge

David Rainey leaving federal court in New Orleans after his arraignment in November 2012. (AP Photo/Matthew Hinton) David Rainey leaving federal court in New Orleans after his arraignment in November 2012. (AP Photo/Matthew Hinton)
MICHAEL KUNZELMAN
Associated Press

NEW ORLEANS (AP) - A federal judge has dismissed a charge that is the backbone of the case against a former BP executive accused of concealing information from Congress about the amount of oil spewing in 2010 from the company's blown-out well in the Gulf of Mexico.

Defense attorney Reid Weingarten called it a huge victory for David Rainey, who was BP's vice president of exploration for the Gulf.

The charge of obstructing Congress thrown out Monday by U.S. District Judge Kurt Engelhardt "was perhaps as much as 90 percent of the government's evidence," Weingarten said.

Rainey still faces one count of making false statements to law enforcement agents.

Engelhardt cited two reasons for dismissing the obstruction of Congress charge against Rainey. One is that the indictment failed to allege that Rainey knew of the pending congressional investigation he was charged with obstructing.

"Because it is an essential element of this crime that the defendant knew of this inquiry and investigation, the indictment must allege such knowledge. It does not," the judge wrote in his 44-page ruling. "Even construing the allegations strongly in the government's favor, it is simply impossible to ascertain from the indictment whether this essential element was presented to and found by the grand jury."

The judge also ruled that the obstruction count must be dismissed because it wasn't clear that it applied to subcommittee investigations like the one at the center of the indictment.

"Although subcommittees exist in both Houses of Congress, the statute does not contain the word 'subcommittee.' Thus, the defendant argues that the Court should not enlarge the statute to include subcommittees,'" Engelhardt wrote.

U.S. Rep. Ed Markey, D-Mass, who led a House subcommittee's investigation of the oil spill, urged the Justice Department to appeal the judge's ruling.

"This was a congressional investigation, plain and simple, and this kind of narrow and off-the wall interpretation of how Congress investigates wrongdoing is deeply troubling," Markey said in a statement.

A Justice Department spokesman said prosecutors were reviewing the decision but declined to comment on it.

The indictment claims Rainey failed to disclose information about the estimated rate that oil was spewing from BP's blown-out Macondo well during a May 4, 2010, congressional briefing. It also claims Rainey responded to a letter from a subcommittee chairman, U.S. Rep. Edward Markey, D-Mass

(Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • Saints survive sloppy performance, beat Jets 31-19

    Saints survive sloppy performance, beat Jets 31-19

    Mark Ingram scored on a 1-yard touchdown. Source: Mark LaGrangeMark Ingram scored on a 1-yard touchdown. Source: Mark LaGrange

    Brandon Coleman lost two fumbles inside the Jets 30-yard line. Drew Brees threw an interception inside the Saints own 20. The Black and Gold lost offensive guard Larry Warford with a concussion right before half. All off these negatives, and the Saints still beat the Jets, 24-19. The Jets came into the contest with a 5-8 record, and played without their starting quarterback. A weakened New York squad no doubt helped out with the final outcome.  Brees went 25-of-35 passing for 2...

    more>>

    Brandon Coleman lost two fumbles inside the Jets 30-yard line. Drew Brees threw an interception inside the Saints own 20. The Black and Gold lost offensive guard Larry Warford with a concussion right before half. All off these negatives, and the Saints still beat the Jets, 24-19. The Jets came into the contest with a 5-8 record, and played without their starting quarterback. A weakened New York squad no doubt helped out with the final outcome.  Brees went 25-of-35 passing for 2...

    more>>
  • Saints hold touchdown advantage over the Jets at half

    Saints hold touchdown advantage over the Jets at half

    Mark Ingram jumped into the stands after his 1-yard TD run. Source: Mark LaGrangeMark Ingram jumped into the stands after his 1-yard TD run. Source: Mark LaGrange
    Sean Payton's squad appears to be getting over their loss to the Falcons quickly, no hangover on this day. The Saints lead the Jets at half, 17-10. The Saints hit the end zone first in the contest with a 1-yard touchdown run by Mark Ingram. His stroll to paydirt gave the Black and Gold a 10-0 advantage. Not to be outdone by his running mate, Alvin Kamara scored on a 10-yard touchdown reception, extending the Saints lead to 17-7. The Jets only touchdown of the first half came on a B...more>>
    Sean Payton's squad appears to be getting over their loss to the Falcons quickly, no hangover on this day. The Saints lead the Jets at half, 17-10. The Saints hit the end zone first in the contest with a 1-yard touchdown run by Mark Ingram. His stroll to paydirt gave the Black and Gold a 10-0 advantage. Not to be outdone by his running mate, Alvin Kamara scored on a 10-yard touchdown reception, extending the Saints lead to 17-7. The Jets only touchdown of the first half came on a B...more>>
  • House fire in Metairie leaves a woman dead

    House fire in Metairie leaves a woman dead

    Source: Nola.comSource: Nola.com

    The Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office says an early morning fire in Metairie has left a woman dead. 

    more>>

    The Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office says an early morning fire in Metairie has left a woman dead. 

    more>>
Powered by Frankly