Ruling could affect Sharper co-defendants - FOX 8, WVUE, fox8live.com, weather, app, news, saints

Ruling could affect Sharper co-defendants

Brandon Licciardi Brandon Licciardi
Erik Nunez Erik Nunez

The 4th Circuit Court of Appeal ruled Tuesday that the Orleans Parish District Attorney's Office could possibly manipulate the process in which judges are selected for some criminal cases.

The ruling would force the Orleans Criminal Court to reselect a judge for the co-defendants of former Saints standout Darren Sharper.

"They're not accusing the DA of doing anything wrong, but what they're saying is this system could be subject to abuse based upon the fact that the DA can arbitrarily come up with a date on a bill of information if they don't have an exact date of a crime that would allow them to dictate a judge that makes it a non-random allotment," said FOX 8 legal analyst Joe Raspanti.

The courts normally select judges based on the date of the crime, but when the crime doesn't have a hard date, like a series of sexual assaults, the DA is allowed to pick an approximate date for the allotment process.

Attorneys for Erik Nunez and Brandon Licciardi argued because the DA used arbitrary dates, he could possibly hand-pick a judge.

In a statement released to FOX 8 Tuesday afternoon, District Attorney Leon Cannizzaro argued there was no prejudice against any defendants:

"I respectfully disagree with the Fourth Circuit’s holding, and my office will seek review in the Louisiana Supreme Court. Not a single judge on the Fourth Circuit found the existence of any evidence that the DA’s office had actually manipulated the allotment process in this case. As such, I find it difficult for the defendants to argue that they suffered any actual prejudice. The present allotment system was the product of a long term collaborative project between my office, the Criminal District Court, and the Public Defenders’ office. The present allotment process constitutes one of the progressive reforms to modernize and streamline what had become a beleaguered criminal justice system in New Orleans.  I believe the recent ruling was a step backwards, and I will seek review in a higher court so that we can continue to move forward for this community and the safety of her citizens."

While the DA's office is already planning to appeal the ruling to the Louisiana Supreme Court, legal experts warn the decision could affect other cases in the criminal court.

"That's the real big issue here that it could affect dozens or hundreds of cases whereby your date was picked arbitrarily, or so you allege, and that could upset the apple cart and have a Pandora's box of all these cases coming back and passing through that building again and that would be a real nightmare, so I'm sure they're going to find some way to avoid that possibility," Raspanti said.

Copyright 2015 WVUE. All rights reserved.

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • Mother of autistic sons awaits medical marijuana

    Mother of autistic sons awaits medical marijuana

    Medical marijuana was supposed to be available in Louisiana next month, but the manual isn't done and the production facility is still under renovation. (Source: Flickr Commons)Medical marijuana was supposed to be available in Louisiana next month, but the manual isn't done and the production facility is still under renovation. (Source: Flickr Commons)

    Louisiana residents awaiting access to medical marijuana will have to wait a little longer. 

    more>>

    Louisiana residents awaiting access to medical marijuana will have to wait a little longer. 

    more>>
  • Saints TE Ben Watson stays steady

    Saints TE Ben Watson stays steady

    Ben Watson remains steady for Saints (Source: Mark LaGrange)Ben Watson remains steady for Saints (Source: Mark LaGrange)
    Ben Watson remains steady for Saints (Source: Mark LaGrange)Ben Watson remains steady for Saints (Source: Mark LaGrange)
    For tight end Ben Watson it's season #15. But he admitted he didn't know if he was going to get there. " I would say that at the end of last year I was very unsure if I was going to continue playing," Watson said." I knew that if I did play there only a very small number of places that I'd consider going.  One of those teams were the saints..because it was here where Watson had the best statistical season of his career in 2015... " There's a combinatio...more>>
    For tight end Ben Watson it's season #15. But he admitted he didn't know if he was going to get there. " I would say that at the end of last year I was very unsure if I was going to continue playing," Watson said." I knew that if I did play there only a very small number of places that I'd consider going.  One of those teams were the saints..because it was here where Watson had the best statistical season of his career in 2015... " There's a combinatio...more>>
  • Coach Payton 'anticipates' Marcus Davenport playing against the Chargers

    Coach Payton 'anticipates' Marcus Davenport playing against the Chargers

    Marcus Davenport has been nursing a groin injury. Source: Nola.comMarcus Davenport has been nursing a groin injury. Source: Nola.com
    Marcus Davenport has been nursing a groin injury. Source: Nola.comMarcus Davenport has been nursing a groin injury. Source: Nola.com

    First-round draft pick Marcus Davenport missed almost three weeks of action during Saints training camp. This weekend, Davenport was back at practice, and all signs point to the rookie playing against the Chargers this Saturday. "The assignment, he'll know. He's been practicing in the meetings. It's just making sure he's 100 percent. But I anticipate that happening this week. I anticipate him being able to work this week and get some playing time," said Sean Payton. The Un...

    more>>

    First-round draft pick Marcus Davenport missed almost three weeks of action during Saints training camp. This weekend, Davenport was back at practice, and all signs point to the rookie playing against the Chargers this Saturday. "The assignment, he'll know. He's been practicing in the meetings. It's just making sure he's 100 percent. But I anticipate that happening this week. I anticipate him being able to work this week and get some playing time," said Sean Payton. The Un...

    more>>
Powered by Frankly